Who Told You That?

Nearly two thousand years ago, the Roman educator Quintilian described the ideal public speaker as vir bonus dicendi peritus: a good person skilled in speaking. For Quintilian, speaking well required more than eloquence, intelligence, or the ability to persuade an audience. The ideal speaker was also a person of good moral character. The ability to influence others carried a responsibility to live according to the goodness one proclaimed. It's an interesting expectation to consider in 2026.

We give people the pulpit, the podium and the lectern. We invite them to lead, persuade, and teach which ultimately shapes our understanding of the world. Some are exceptionally gifted communicators. Others derive their influence from the positions they occupy and the authority we give them. In either case, their words carry weight, and we often trust them to guide us toward what is true, good, or right. But how often do we consider whether the person exercising that influence is actually good? And further, should it matter?

The Goodness of the Speaker

The ability to lead someone toward a conclusion is not the same as the moral authority to lead them there. A gifted speaker may lack moral integrity, just as a person of admirable character may struggle to persuade an audience. Quintilian's ideal recognizes that these are distinct qualities, but argues that both belong in the person entrusted with influencing others. To understand why, we have to consider what actually happens when someone speaks and another person listens.

Communication is more than the delivery of information from one person to another. The speaker brings a message, an understanding of the world, and a particular relationship to the audience. The audience brings their own knowledge, experiences, and assumptions. Together, we are co-creators of meaning.

Whether listening to a sermon, considering a political argument, or learning from a teacher, we interpret what we hear through our own experiences, evaluate it against what we know, and incorporate it into our understanding of the world. But… and this is an important but…. the speaker's character and conduct become part of that process, influencing not only how we understand the message but also how we relate to the values it communicates.

Consider someone who teaches compassion, integrity, or forgiveness. Their message resonates with us, maybe it even changes how we understand ourselves or treat others. But what happens when we discover that this person has no intention of practicing the values they teach? The principles themselves may still be true, yet our relationship with them changes. We begin to question not only the sincerity of the speaker but also the value of the principles themselves. Is goodness something people genuinely strive toward, or merely something they profess?

There is, of course, a difference between human imperfection and moral duplicity. We all make mistakes, contradict our own values, and struggle to practice what we believe. But striving toward goodness and deliberately exempting ourselves from its demands are fundamentally different things. When someone teaches a moral standard they have no intention of following, the consequences extend beyond their own hypocrisy to the people who have trusted them.

Where Goodness Matters

Consider the church. A preacher stands before a congregation teaching love, forgiveness, humility, and righteousness. The congregation trusts this person to help them understand and practice their faith. But when religious leaders abuse those entrusted to their care, the consequences can reach into the foundations of belief itself. The teachings and the speaker have become intertwined through years of shared understanding and spiritual formation. When the church leader’s conduct contradicts those teachings, people may begin to question not only the person they trusted but also their own understanding of the goodness they learned from them. Some leave their churches. Others question their faith. Still others continue believing but struggle to reconcile the goodness they were taught with the conduct of those who claimed to represent it.

In politics, leaders appeal to justice, honesty, responsibility, freedom, and the common good, asking us to trust their judgment and grant them authority over decisions that affect our lives. We participate in that relationship through our votes, our support, and our willingness to believe that the principles they proclaim will guide their decisions. But when those same leaders repeatedly violate those principles, we are left to reconcile their promises with their actual conduct. What does accountability mean when those in power demand it of their opponents but refuse to practice it themselves? What does integrity mean when it appears to be little more than a campaign strategy? Over time, these contradictions can change how we understand the values themselves. Eventually, the question becomes whether principled leadership is even possible.

Education presents another consequence, one that extends across generations. Teachers help shape how young people understand fairness, integrity, intellectual honesty, respect, and civic responsibility. Students encounter these values through classroom instruction, but they also learn what those values mean by watching the adults entrusted with teaching them. When an educator demands honesty but practices deception, teaches respect but humiliates students, or insists on accountability while refusing to accept responsibility for their own conduct, the lesson extends far beyond the intended curriculum. Students may begin to understand these values as expectations imposed by authority rather than principles worth living by. And as those students become adults, they carry that understanding into their relationships, workplaces, communities, and civic responsibilities. We are not simply teaching young people what goodness means. We are helping them determine whether goodness is worth practicing.

Whose Responsibility Is It?

When leaders fail to live according to the goodness they proclaim, we naturally blame the leaders themselves. We expect accountability. We want them to acknowledge their failures, correct their conduct, and take responsibility for the harm they have caused. While those expectations are reasonable because the moral responsibility of someone exercising influence remains significant, there is another responsible party in this relationship.

Us.

We often approach authority as though the person speaking has already earned the right to define what is true or good or right. We assume that education, professional position, religious office, or political success establishes the credibility of the person occupying that role. Yet the permission to exercise influence is not proof that someone deserves our blind trust. And more importantly, for all of these offices, moral authority cannot be established simply because someone occupies the role.

Otherwise, we find ourselves in a circular argument. We accept someone's definition of goodness because we believe that person is good, and we believe that person is good because they satisfy the definition they have given us. There must be some way of evaluating the truth beyond the person claiming it. And, this is where discernment becomes essential.

Christine de Pizan and the Practice of Discernment

In the early fifteenth century, Christine de Pizan writes The Book of the City of Ladies. She opens with a scene from her study. Surrounded by books, she describes her encounter with a work that disparages women, portraying them as morally and intellectually inferior. She sets it aside in favor of more worthwhile reading, but the encounter leaves her thinking about the many respected philosophers, poets, and scholars who have made similar claims about women's inferiority.

Christine examines these claims against her own knowledge and experiences with women across social classes and finds them inconsistent with what she knows to be true. Yet she describes surrendering her judgment to the reputations of the men making them, admitting that she relied more on the judgment of others than on what she herself felt and knew. The irony is striking.

Christine has already demonstrated the intellectual capacity to evaluate these arguments, yet she presents herself as accepting the authority of men whose conclusions contradict her own observations. Her apparent submission exposes the danger of allowing reputation to substitute for reason. Through an allegory featuring Lady Reason, Lady Rectitude, and Lady Justice, Christine challenges these ideas. When she brings up Cicero's argument that serving a woman lowers a man's status, Lady Reason responds that a person's worth comes from virtue, not sex or social position. When Christine raises Cato's claim that men would converse with gods if women did not exist, Lady Reason uses Christian theology to show the flaws in his reasoning.

Christine does more than question what these men have said. She offers a different understanding of women, using examples of their character, abilities, and accomplishments. And she does this through the very kind of careful thinking these men claimed women were incapable of. She uses her knowledge and skill as a writer to challenge harmful ideas and offer something better.

Christine gives us an example of both sides of Quintilian's ideal. She questions the authority of others, but she also takes responsibility for how she uses her own voice. Her work asks readers to do the same: to think about what they're being told, compare it with what they know, and decide whether the argument holds up. This is discernment.

The Practice of Discernment

Discernment can sound like an abstract virtue, something reserved for philosophers, theologians, or people with extraordinary wisdom. But its practice is remarkably concrete. What this practically means is:

  1. We begin by examining what we are being told. What is the claim? What is being presented as true, good, necessary, or right?

  2. Then we consider what we know. How does that claim compare with our knowledge, our lived experience, and what we can observe? What in our experience supports it? What experience challenges it?

  3. And finally, we examine its impact. What happens when this teaching is put into practice? What does it cultivate in the people who encounter it? What are its consequences, both intended and unintended?

In other words, we look at the fruit.

We consider the full circumstances rather than accepting a message solely because of the person delivering it. A speaker's failure does not automatically invalidate everything they have taught. Neither does the truth of a message excuse the speaker's harmful conduct. We can acknowledge both without allowing one to erase the other.

Of course, our own understanding deserves examination, too. Our experiences give us valuable knowledge, but they also shape our assumptions. We may have misunderstood something, overlooked evidence, or accepted an idea simply because it is familiar. And sometimes, examining those assumptions means questioning beliefs we have held for years or people whose judgment we have always trusted.

That is where discernment becomes more difficult. We may recognize contradictions in what we are taught and still choose to overlook them. Because, questioning someone we trust, challenging the expectations of our community, or reconsidering a belief that has shaped our lives can have consequences. So, sometimes it’s just easier to accept what others have already decided than to examine it for ourselves.

Christine de Pizan lived in a world where generations of respected thinkers had already decided what women were capable of. She had her own knowledge and experience to draw upon, but challenging those claims meant questioning the judgment of people whose authority had long been accepted.

The same choice confronts us when we examine the beliefs, traditions, and expectations that shape our understanding of the world. We may discover that what we have always believed is true. We may discover something different. Either way, we must be willing to look.

Because discernment requires more than the ability to think.

It requires courage.

And sometimes, the most courageous thing we can do is simply decide to look for ourselves.

Next
Next

Let’s Play Cards